5 min read

Schools to shut for 3rd day as union debate rages

If you include the one-day work stoppage in 2016, this is the 5th contentious work stoppage within the last 10 years between the CTU and CPS, and the 4th within the last 6 years.
Schools to shut for 3rd day as union debate rages

Embed from Getty Images

By SOPHIA TAREEN | Associated Press

CHICAGO (AP) — Leaders of the nation’s third-largest school district canceled classes for a third consecutive day amid increasingly tough negotiations with the Chicago Teachers Union over remote learning and other COVID-19 safety measures.

The union, which voted this week to revert to online instruction, told teachers not to show up to schools starting Wednesday during the latest COVID-19 surge while both sides negotiate.[1] The move just two days after students returned from winter break prompted district officials to cancel classes each day for students in the roughly 350,000-student district during negotiations, saying there's no plan to return to districtwide remote instruction.[2]

Most school districts nationwide have confronted the same pandemic issues, with most opting to stay open while ramping up virus testing, tweaking protocols, and other adjustments in response to the shifting pandemic.

In a Thursday message to parents, Chicago leaders said classes would be canceled Friday but “in-person learning and activities may be available at a small number of schools” based on how many staff come to schools. A small percentage of teachers, along with substitutes, have continued to report to work during what the district has labeled an “illegal work stoppage.”

Some schools preemptively alerted parents earlier Thursday that they didn't have enough staff and wouldn't accept students aside from offering meal pickup in the largely low-income and Black and Latino district. The district said roughly 10% of about 21,620 teachers came to work Wednesday and by Thursday it was nearly 13%.

“Our schools are the best, safest place for students to be during this pandemic, and we are working tirelessly to get everyone back in class every day,” Schools CEO Pedro Martinez said in a statement Thursday evening. “We will continue working with CTU to resolve this situation and will provide you with ongoing updates as the week continues.”

Chicago schools leaders have rejected a return to remote learning, saying it worsens racial inequities and is detrimental to academic performance, mental health and attendance. District officials have spent about $100 million on its safety plan, including air purifiers in classrooms.

In Chicago, there was little sign Thursday that either side was softening — the district and union both filed labor complaints with the state this week as negotiations continued. Issues on the table include more testing and metrics to trigger school closures.

The union has blasted the district for not doing enough, like botching a testing program and maintaining unreliable data on infections in schools.[3] They’ve sought demands similar to a safety agreement put in place last year after a fierce debate.[4] However, the district says the pandemic is different now than a year ago and requires a different response, particularly since 91% of school staff is vaccinated.

Mayor Lori Lightfoot accused the union of politicizing a pandemic, while the union's president, Jesse Sharkey, dubbed her “Lockout Lori," because teachers haven't been able to log into remote-learning systems since early Wednesday.

“Enough is enough,” Lightfoot said during a Thursday morning interview on MSNBC. “I’m tired of the Groundhog Day appearance of everything that goes on with the Chicago Teachers Union leadership. We need partnership, we don’t need conflict. “

Sharkey said Lightfoot is wrong to blame teachers.

“We have rights to safety and we’ve been at the bargaining table for 20 months to secure those rights,” he wrote in an email to members. “We haven’t shifted the goal posts one bit; in fact, we’ve been saying the same thing for months: Please, work WITH us to set up comprehensive testing, work with us to vaccinate students, and work with us to establish basic guard rails.”

The district argued in a complaint to the Illinois Educational Labor Relations Board that the union’s actions are an illegal work stoppage, and sought a cease and desist order and a ban on future illegal strikes.

The union’s complaint argued members have a right to refuse “hazardous work assignments” and accused the district of an illegal lockout by canceling classes and barring access to remote-teaching tools. It asked the board to order Chicago schools to allow remote instruction until a new safety agreement is reached.

It was unclear Thursday when the board may act, but the process could take weeks to play out. In December 2020, the board rejected the union’s request to block the district from resuming in-person instruction in January 2021.

The pattern was familiar for Chicago parents. The teachers union has threatened to strike during contentious bargaining over school conditions for decades, and last walked off the job in 2012 and in 2019, when talks with the city broke down.[5][6] There was also a one-day work stoppage in 2016 over unfair labor practices.[7]

Attendance was low in schools at the start of the week with thousands of students in quarantine related to a COVID-19 case and others opting to stay home to avoid exposure. The World Health Organization likened the explosion of COVID-19 cases to a “tsunami."[8] CPS reported 433 student infections on Tuesday, its highest daily total, according to district data.

Still, many families were frustrated by having to again make last-minute arrangements and wondered whether being out of school might contribute to the spread.

“It’s almost contradictory because like now these kids and their parents have to find some activities for the children when they’re not in school and they’re with other kids en masse now," said parent Mary Bluma, who has three children in Chicago schools. "So it’s almost like, oh, there’s probably a better chance they’re going to spread COVID or, you know, get sick from other kids because now we’re not in a structured environment like a classroom where there are rules in place.”

Associated Press writers Sara Burnett, Kathleen Foody and Don Babwin, and AP videographer Teresa Crawford contributed to this report.

The Chicago Journal needs your support.

At just $20/year, your subscription not only helps us grow, it helps maintain our commitment to independent publishing and remain free from influence.


Follow Sophia Tareen on Twitter: https://twitter.com/sophiatareen.

Notes & References

  1. Chicago Journal. “CTU Walks out on Schools Again.” Chicago Journal. Chicago Journal, January 5, 2022. https://www.chicagojournal.com/ctu-walks-out-on-schools-again/. ↩︎

  2. Chicago Journal. “CPS to Cancel Classes Tomorrow If CTU Votes Remote Tonight.” Chicago Journal. Chicago Journal, January 5, 2022. https://www.chicagojournal.com/cps-to-cancel-classes-tomorrow-if-ctu-votes-for-remote-later-tonight/. ↩︎

  3. “Chicago Union Says City School's COVID Tracker Inaccurate.” AP NEWS. Associated Press, September 9, 2021. https://apnews.com/article/health-chicago-coronavirus-pandemic-chicago-teachers-union-e8d47cebad6b23f3dd2ff7ce33da261f. ↩︎

  4. Babwin, Don. “Union Approves Deal with Chicago Schools to Return to Class.” AP NEWS. Associated Press, February 10, 2021. https://apnews.com/article/us-news-education-coronavirus-pandemic-strikes-chicago-87ecfdf4a785641155fb822016966786. ↩︎

  5. Webber, Tammy. “After Teachers Strike, Doubts about Implications.” AP NEWS. Associated Press, September 20, 2012. https://apnews.com/article/business-chicago-strikes-rahm-emanuel-2fbca28cd56c423dbcb3dfa4e43651ec. ↩︎

  6. Foody, Kathleen. “Chicago Teachers Strike Ends after 11 Days without School.” AP NEWS. Associated Press, October 31, 2019. https://apnews.com/article/chicago-schools-us-news-ap-top-news-strikes-international-news-424b63b8d83f4511bdd114bb8cb87710. ↩︎

  7. “Chicago Teachers Vote to Authorize Strike in Contract Talks.” AP NEWS. Associated Press, September 26, 2016. https://apnews.com/9956517144ca4897a46cd7c83bfed6c9. ↩︎

  8. Keaten, Jamey. “Who: Record Weekly Jump in Covid-19 Cases but Fewer Deaths.” AP NEWS. Associated Press, January 6, 2022. https://apnews.com/article/coronavirus-pandemic-health-pandemics-united-nations-tsunamis-c8fcd112c41016547cfedc94b5e8460e. ↩︎